Food Science
Why Does Swiss Cheese Have Holes—and Do They Matter in Grilled Cheese?
The holes in Swiss cheese are a result of ripening, not a meltability score. Here is what cheese eyes actually tell you—and how to keep them from leaving bare bites in grilled cheese.
A slice of Swiss cheese can look generous until you lay it on bread. Suddenly, five round windows reveal five bare patches. Add a second slice and two of the holes line up perfectly, as if the cheese planned it.
That creates three reasonable questions. Are the holes just empty space you paid for? Do they make the cheese melt differently? And do you need extra cheese to get a complete grilled cheese?
The short answer is reassuring: the holes—properly called eyes—are part of how Swiss-style cheese ripens. They do not make the cheese inherently better or worse at melting, and they do not mean a weighed package contains less cheese than its label states. They can create uneven coverage in one particular sandwich, but that is an assembly problem with a simple fix: use the same total weight of cheese and overlap thin pieces so the gaps do not align.
The eyes are interesting science. The overlap is useful lunch.
The quick answer
Swiss-style cheese develops eyes when carbon dioxide produced during ripening collects inside an elastic cheese body. The familiar round openings depend on more than gas alone: bacterial activity, temperature, salt, the way carbon dioxide moves through the cheese, the firmness of the curd, and microscopic starting points all influence where eyes form and how large they become.
For grilled cheese, remember four things:
- Eyes are not a meltability rating. A cheese's moisture, acidity, mineral balance, fat, age, and protein structure matter more to the way it softens and flows.
- Buy and portion by weight. A prepackaged block or stack is labeled by net weight, not by the apparent area of each slice.
- Coverage still matters. One large eye can leave a bread-only bite even when the total cheese portion is adequate.
- Overlap instead of overfilling. Two thinner, offset layers or several overlapping pieces cover bread more evenly than one thick slice with the same holes in the same places.
How Swiss cheese gets its eyes
Swiss-style cheese is made in stages, and different microbes do different jobs.
Starter bacteria first turn milk sugar into lactic acid. During later warm ripening, propionic-acid bacteria—commonly Propionibacterium freudenreichii in Swiss-type cheesemaking—use lactate and produce propionate, acetate, and carbon dioxide. Some of that carbon dioxide dissolves in the cheese. As more accumulates, it moves toward places where a bubble can begin and expand. If the cheese body is elastic enough, pressure opens a rounded space instead of a jagged crack.
That space becomes an eye.
This is why “bacteria make gas” is true but incomplete. Gas production is only one part of eye formation. The gas also needs somewhere to gather, and the cheese must be able to stretch around it.
Researchers have shown how sensitive the result can be. In experimental Swiss-type cheeses, changing salt exposure and the bacterial culture changed eye volume, diameter, and placement. Other work found that ripening-film permeability changed how much carbon dioxide escaped and altered the number and size of openings. The wheel is not simply inflated like a balloon; it is a changing protein-and-water matrix in which gas production, diffusion, and structure interact.
The strange but important role of microscopic starting points
For years, cheesemakers and researchers knew that very clean, highly filtered milk could produce too few eyes. A 2015 study from Swiss researchers found that trace amounts of powdered hay promoted eye formation in experimental Emmental cheese. The plant microparticles acted as eye nuclei—starting points around which an opening could develop.
Newer research sharpened the explanation. In a 2026 experiment, researchers used synthetic hollow fibers and tiny tube pieces with standardized capillary structures. The pieces trapped microscopic air pockets, and eyes formed around them. Control cheeses without those capillary structures tended to make very few eyes and more cracks because the carbon dioxide had no comparable nuclei into which it could diffuse.
This does not mean a deli slice is full of visible hay. The tested quantities and structures were microscopic, and the point is about nucleation: gas needs a favorable place to begin an opening. It is the same broad reason bubbles form more readily at tiny scratches in a glass of sparkling water than in a perfectly smooth container.
The practical lesson is that eye count is not a simple measure of “more bacteria” or “better cheese.” It reflects an entire manufacturing and ripening system.
Is every cheese with holes Swiss cheese?
No. Small openings can develop in several cheese styles, and they do not all arise from the same process or produce the same flavor.
In the United States, the federal standard of identity for “Swiss cheese” or “emmentaler cheese” describes a cheese made with lactic-acid-producing and propionic-acid-producing cultures, with eyes developed throughout the cheese. It also sets composition and aging requirements. That legal category is useful when reading a label, but it does not make every cheese with an opening interchangeable.
An imported Emmentaler, a domestic deli Swiss, and another Alpine-style cheese may differ in age, moisture, salt, sweetness, nuttiness, firmness, and eye size. A cheese can also have small mechanical openings or irregular cracks that are not the classic round eyes of Swiss-type ripening.
Use the name and ingredient statement as clues, then pay attention to the specific cheese in front of you.
Are you paying for the holes?
Not in the way the joke suggests.
Prepackaged food labels declare a net quantity, and solid food such as cheese is ordinarily declared by weight. Random-weight cheese at a deli is also priced from the weight placed on the scale. A 12-ounce package contains a declared 12 ounces of product whether the cheese has many visible eyes or almost none.
The holes can change how much surface area one slice covers, but they do not subtract from the labeled net weight. A broad, thin slice with large eyes may cover more bread while weighing the same as a smaller, thicker slice with fewer eyes. What you see is geometry, not missing ounces.
That distinction matters at the cutting board. Weight tells you how much cheese you have. Arrangement tells you where it will land.
If you want a repeatable starting point, our weight-based grilled-cheese test begins around 2 ounces, or 55 grams, for standard sandwich bread. Keep the portion steady while you change the layout.
Do the eyes change how Swiss cheese melts?
The holes change local coverage. They do not change the fundamental melt behavior of the cheese surrounding them.
Imagine two 55-gram portions cut from the same block. One is a single thick slice with four large eyes. The other is cut into thin overlapping pieces. The protein, water, fat, salt, acidity, and age are the same. Both portions will soften according to the same underlying cheese structure. The second arrangement simply spreads that structure across more of the bread.
Cheese melt is governed by a network of casein proteins, water, fat, minerals, and acid. Research on cheese functionality has repeatedly found that pH, calcium, moisture, salt, ripening, and heating conditions can change softness, flow, and oil separation. The geometry of an eye may leave a temporary gap, but it does not act like an ingredient that makes the neighboring cheese resistant to heat.
That is also why two Swiss-style cheeses can behave differently even if their holes look similar. A younger, moister deli Swiss may soften readily. A firmer, longer-aged cheese may become supple and aromatic without flowing as freely. If a cheese remains tight or releases oil, adding heat until the bread burns will not fix its structure. Our guide to why some cheeses do not melt the same way explains how to use a more flavorful, less-flowing cheese in a blend.
The simplest coverage fix: offset the layers
You do not need to eliminate every visible pinhole. You are trying to avoid a few large gaps lining up from bread to bread.
For one standard sandwich:
- Weigh your usual cheese portion. Start near 55 grams if you do not have a baseline.
- If the cheese is deli-sliced, ask for thin slices rather than one heavy slice.
- Lay the first slice slightly left of center.
- Rotate or shift the second slice so its eyes sit over cheese, not over the first slice's eyes.
- Tear any remaining cheese into strips and cover the exposed corners.
- Stop when the weighed portion is used. Do not keep adding slices merely because one tiny opening remains.
If you are cutting from a block, thin rectangles are easier to distribute than one slab. Shreds also solve the coverage problem, though a classic Swiss-style cheese can be firm enough that hand shredding takes more effort than layering slices.
The useful measure is not perfect visual coverage before cooking. It is whether the melted cheese connects into a mostly continuous layer while the sandwich remains balanced and manageable.
An equal-weight test you can run at home
If the holes still seem like they must matter, test the arrangement rather than arguing with the slice.
What you need
- Four matching bread slices
- One Swiss-style cheese
- A kitchen scale
- The same exterior spread for both sandwiches
- One skillet
Build two sandwiches
For sandwich A, weigh 55 grams of cheese and use it in the fewest pieces possible. Let the large eyes fall where they fall.
For sandwich B, weigh the same 55 grams, then cut or fold it into thinner pieces. Overlap them so the largest gaps do not line up.
Cook both sandwiches over the same moderate heat, turning when the first side is evenly browned rather than chasing an exact number of minutes. Rest each sandwich for a minute on a rack, then cut through comparable sections.
Score three things:
- Are there bread-only bites near the center or corners?
- Is the cheese equally soft and cohesive?
- Does one sandwich feel overfilled, or did the layout solve the problem without adding weight?
The likely difference is distribution, not melting. Sandwich B should give you more consistent coverage with no extra cheese.
When the holes are actually useful information
Eyes do tell you something: the cheese went through a gas-forming ripening process and had a body capable of developing openings. In regulated U.S. Swiss or emmentaler cheese, eyes are part of the standard description.
But the hole pattern is a poor shortcut for many shopping decisions. Large eyes do not guarantee a stronger nutty flavor. Small eyes do not guarantee a creamier melt. A wheel with fewer eyes is not automatically younger, cheaper, or defective. The relationship between eye formation and the finished cheese is too dependent on culture, salt, temperature, ripening, gas diffusion, and structure for those one-glance conclusions.
For grilled cheese, use more direct clues:
- Texture at refrigerator temperature: A flexible slice is usually easier to distribute than a brittle one.
- Age and moisture: These help explain whether the cheese will flow freely or stay more defined.
- Flavor intensity: A mild deli Swiss can carry the sandwich; a more assertive Alpine-style cheese may work best as part of a blend.
- Cut: Thin, overlapping slices give more even coverage than one thick slab.
- Weight: A repeatable portion prevents a coverage fix from becoming an overfilled sandwich.
A better way to look at the slice
The holes in Swiss cheese are not missing cheese. They are the visible record of fermentation, gas movement, microscopic nucleation, and a curd elastic enough to open without simply cracking.
In a sandwich, that history creates one small job: arrange the cheese so the gaps do not stack.
Keep the weight the same. Slice thinly. Offset the layers. Then let the cheese's flavor—not the empty circles—be what you notice.
Sources and further reading
- Guggisberg, D., Bisig, W., and Fröhlich-Wyder, M.-T. (2026). Nuclei carrying entrapped air are the most likely starting points for eye formation. International Dairy Journal, 176, 106573.
- Guggisberg, D., et al. (2015). Mechanism and control of the eye formation in cheese. International Dairy Journal, 47, 118–127.
- Bisig, W., et al. (2019). The effect of NaCl and metabolic profile of propionibacteria on eye formation in experimental Swiss-type cheese. International Dairy Journal, 89, 86–95.
- Bisig, W., et al. (2026). CO2 permeability of plastic ripening films and of natural dry ripening influences eye formation in experimental Emmentaler cheese. International Dairy Journal.
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration. 21 CFR § 133.195: Swiss and emmentaler cheese.
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration. 21 CFR § 101.7: Declaration of net quantity of contents.
- McMahon, D. J., et al. (2005). Influence of calcium, pH, and moisture on protein matrix structure and functionality in direct-acidified nonfat mozzarella cheese. Journal of Dairy Science, 88(11), 3754–3763.